opinion

"Self-Defense or Self-Service? Austin Cop’s Shooting Trial Exposes APD’s Paperwork Magic"

In the latest episode of "Austin PD: Whoops, We Did It Again," an officer's questionable shooting goes to trial, complete with last-minute evidence dumps and the usual "I feared for my life" defense.

Alex Jaxon

By Alex Jaxon

Published June 23, 2025 at 8:30pm


Oh, what a shocker—another Austin police officer embroiled in a "misunderstanding" that just so happens to involve a dead civilian. The trial over the 2021 shooting of Alex Gonzales Jr. kicked off this week, and let me tell you, folks, the theatrics are already Oscar-worthy. Officer Gabriel Gutierrez, the star of this tragicomedy, claims he was just defending himself when he shot Gonzales during a road rage incident. Because, you know, nothing says "self-defense" like unloading bullets into someone and then letting another officer finish the job. Classic APD teamwork!

The plaintiffs’ attorneys are spinning quite the yarn, accusing Gutierrez of lying to investigators and the Austin Police Department of conducting a "sham" investigation. But come on, who are we kidding? Since when has APD ever botched an investigation? Oh wait—gestures broadly at the last decade of headlines. The real kicker? The city conveniently "found" 2,200 pages of investigative records six days before the trial. How very... timely. Almost like they were hoping no one would notice. But hey, what’s a little last-minute document dump between friends?

Gutierrez’s lawyer, Albert Lopez, is sticking to the tried-and-true cop defense: "My client feared for his life." Ah yes, the magical incantation that turns any questionable shooting into a justified one. Never mind that the gun in Gonzales’ car was loaded but not chambered—details, details! And let’s not forget the city’s bold claim that APD takes these investigations very seriously. Sure, Gray Laird, sure. Next you’ll tell us Austin’s traffic isn’t that bad and the bats are just misunderstood.

Meanwhile, the plaintiffs’ expert witness, Steve Chancellor, dropped the bombshell that reconstructing shootings is, in fact, important. Groundbreaking stuff, really. Who would’ve thought that knowing where people were standing during a shooting might be relevant? Certainly not APD, who apparently misplaced that memo—along with those 2,200 pages.

So here we are, folks, watching yet another episode of Cops Gone Wild: Austin Edition. Will justice prevail? Will APD finally admit they might’ve, just maybe, screwed up? Or will this case disappear into the bureaucratic abyss like so many before it? Stay tuned—same cop time, same cop channel.